Select Page

Award winning pizza from a Petoskey landmark.

 Pick up or Delivery Only

Cutting no corners and using only the finest, freshest ingredients available.



View Menu

Our Story

Established in 1966

At just 8’ wide and 60’ long, and once an alleyway, the Mighty Fine Pizza building is now known as, “The hardest working 480 square feet in Petoskey!”

The building originated in 1966 and was Petoskey’s first pizza place. In 1993 Bill Schmidt Sr. and Bill Schmidt Jr. went into a father/son venture, bought the place and dedicated themselves to producing the best quality pizza possible. In 2012 Mighty Fine Pizza was purchased by Earl and Ambre Flynn of Petoskey. Earl Flynn was a previous Mighty Fine Pizza employee in the early 1990s.


Homemade Dough 

Mighty Fine Pizza makes fresh homemade dough daily for only the very best pizza crust and bread sticks.

Fresh Ingredients

You’ll find fresh and local products chopped and prepped by hand; we cut no corners when it comes to quality or taste.

Homemade Pizza Sauce, Dressings, and Dips

There is nothing canned or franchised about Mighty Fine Pizza. All sauces, dips, and dressings are made from scratch.


What People are Saying

“GREAT food every time!”

“Order the Flynn pizza and by all means get the added sauerkraut. You won’t be disappointed

Bob Reed

“Friendly Staff”

The Sweet Escape is the best burger I have ever had in my life. Dried cherries, bacon, thick patty, cheese, and mango bourbon sauce. Phenomenal! Had the calzone with bacon The other day as well, delicious. My favorite pizza/burger place in town.

Darek J.


Great service, quality food, and family-owned. If you are looking to try something a little less traditional, their bacon cheeseburger pizza is amazing!.

Haley R.

“Definitely a Good Value”

Great pizza! Sweet sauce and thick crust. The dough was very good and cooked perfectly. Not to mention the view while waiting for it. The pizza came up fast and the price was fair.

Mike J.

Hours of Operation




Pick Up or Delivery Only


 Monday - Thursday

 11 am -9 pm



 11 am-10 pm



 3 pm-10 pm



 3 pm-8 pm  


Drop Us a Line


222 E. Mitchell St.
Petoskey, MI 49770


Mighty Fine Pizza Winter Specials