Award winning pizza from a Petoskey landmark.
Pick up or Delivery Only
Cutting no corners and using only the finest, freshest ingredients available.
Our Story
Established in 1966
The building originated in 1966 and was Petoskey’s first pizza place. In 1993 Bill Schmidt Sr. and Bill Schmidt Jr. went into a father/son venture, bought the place and dedicated themselves to producing the best quality pizza possible. In 2012 Mighty Fine Pizza was purchased by Earl and Ambre Flynn of Petoskey. Earl Flynn was a previous Mighty Fine Pizza employee in the early 1990s.
Homemade Dough
Fresh Ingredients
Homemade Pizza Sauce, Dressings, and Dips
Testimonials
What People are Saying
“GREAT food every time!”
Bob Reed
“Friendly Staff”
Darek J.
“LOVE! LOVE! LOVE!”
Haley R.
“Definitely a Good Value”
Mike J.
Hours of Operation
Pick Up or Delivery Only
For special hours, please check our social media!
Monday - Thursday
11 am -9 pm
Friday
11 am-10 pm
Saturday
3 pm-10 pm
Sunday
3 pm-8 pm